What I think can often be the biggest issue after d-day is that we might tell our spouse to do something and then we wait. We are placing a lot of power to the WS in the hope that they start to do stuff to make things better.
Well... I have a slightly different strategy... a subtle difference. It still places a lot of work on the WS, but it also gives us the BS a lot of power.
Basically it goes like this. Tell your wife something along the following lines (maybe condense it but you hopefully get the gist):
"Wife – I am not clear on what I want. I don’t know if I want to work on this marriage or divorce. I don’t know if you are capable of change to make you a safe partner or not. I don’t know if reconciliation is really an option even if I had some hopes for it. What I do know is this:
I won’t rush any decision – mainly due to the kids. This doesn’t mean I will remain married to you no matter what – but simply what I stated: I won’t rush any decision.
I know you have had two affairs. What this tells me is that you have at least twice thought that having an affair was something you could do and was a great idea. It doesn’t tell me it was only twice, nor does it tell me that you will not have yet another affair.
I know that there is nothing I did that could have logically made you decide to have these affairs, therefore there is little I can change to prevent you from reaching the same decision again.
I admit I dread losing you. But even more I dread discovering a new ongoing affair. I dread sharing you, and I don’t share my wife. If you aren’t in this marriage then I have already lost you and hanging on is like trying to resuscitate a corpse.
I realize that the laws and procedures here would make a divorce fair. There would be major lifestyle-changes and changes in how we deal with our kids, but people have dealt with all that successfully. It would beat being in a home where this level of disrespect is shown to a spouse. Although I’m not clear on what I want, then I am 100% certain that a divorce beats a new discovery of an ongoing affair some months or years from now.
I don’t have any reason to believe you have changed simply because I discovered this last affair. I can’t change you. I don’t want to change you. If you want change you need to want it, get it and implement it yourself.
What I DO KNOW is that I want out of infidelity. The ONLY path that is totally 100% within MY power to get out of infidelity is by ending our marital relationship. The other path – reconciliation – is 100% dependent on you wanting it as much as I might want it, and 100% dependent on you making changes and convincing me of those changes so that I don’t have to constantly be doubting you.
What I am offering you is this:
You are totally free to decide what you want. It would be best if you told me what you want in a clear and unequivocal way, but until you do so then I’m simply assuming – based on your past – that you want to continue having affairs. Therefore I am now setting you free of all marital obligations.
You can see OM, date OM, communicate with OM, have sex – virtual or physical – with OM, talk about OM with friends and family... But not as my wife.
Although I am not clear on R or D then I do know that until you let me know what YOU want then D is really my only option. Therefore I am placing my emphasis and focus on divorce, and will start the long process of detaching emotionally, physically and practically.
There is no rush, this takes time and some preparation. We can do this amicably and definitely with our kids’ best interest in mind.
Like I said at the start: I don’t know what I want – R or D – but this is based on what I know I can get as-is.
If you were to make it clear to me that you want this marriage, then I have some non-negotiable requirements. If you comply with them then that would increase the odds I chose to reconcile.
Those requirements are:
Total accountability and truth. I need to know if there are more, if there were attempts, how you met them, how it started, what took place, who knows...
Keep in mind that NOW I’m willing to hear hard truths. Discovering something you hid or lied about some months from now is likely to cause more damage than learning about it now.
IC for you. Why do you think you are allowed to do this? Why do you do it? What is lacking in YOU?
Total openness about digital media, social events, daily schedule... I realize I need to rebuild trust but for now there is none. I don’t know where you are for two hours and I’m assuming you are meeting another man.
MC somewhere down the road. As is, while I am more focused on how we best separate then the cost of MC is better used in other areas. Plus, it’s not the marriage that cheated.
Then add whatever you feel is needed.
Once this discussion is done then don’t wait for her reply. Move on. Go make a sandwich...
She comes and tells you she has had the affair because you work too much or don’t support her sports-team or whatever.... the standard reply is:
"If we were working on our marriage then this might be a relevant issue. Since however you are focused on your affairs then we don’t have to go there"
It’s not until she gives you what is basically an unconditional surrender that you start talking marital issues, or making joint marital plans. And even then – only slowly. She still needs to comply with all the requirements and you need to establish a feeling that she’s being truthful.